Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Liz Rosenberg on Lady Gaga and Madonna - Born This Way


Liz Rosenberg has issued a statement saying:

"I am not aware that Madonna sent Gaga an email. That's all I have to say on the matter.''



20 comments:

  1. Oh god...... Lady kaka! The slut looks like a garden lizard.
    On the day of grammy in a news channel in india, the reader said, "the queen of reinvention after madonna- ms.gaga hatched out of an egg on the stage and performed her latest single born this way." i don't know how these people could call gaga the queen of reinvention who always tries new but becomes more and more disastrous. I've never seen her dressed like a human being. Her fashion is always a nightmare for ordinary people. But madonna is really a fashion phenomenon. Though i've got a great love for gaga, i'll never say that she looks fabulous in her experimental outfits.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm glad you posted this. I've seen it on other M websites and hope it gets wider exposure. Shall we all start Tweeting this news?! Lady Gaga is either supremely arrogant or nuts if she thinks she can get away with outright lying about Madonna. She's playing everyone for falls and ain't gonna get away with it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. munwar, u crack me up... "the slut looks like a garden lizard" and "Though i've got a great love for gaga, i'll never say that she looks fabulous.." lol, thats quite a range of love and disgust. but that's what lady gag brings out in people. personally i don't hear "express yourself" when i listen to "born this way" but when she rolled outta that egg with an "i dream of jeanie" ponytail at the grammys i was pissed. she's got sharon gal at her becon call (m's make-up artist from blond ambition era... uhh, yea), she wears Gautlier corsets & bullet bras, she's got steven klein knocking off M's classic videos on her behalf, and now she's rocking the ponytail from BAT??? get off madonna's fuckin nutz already!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think everybody should know that Gaga is a fucking liar. I just can't stand the comparisons with Madonna. It's demeaning for Madonna. How can people compare a woman with 30 years of a brilliant career with a 3 years career troll

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello mystery machine...
    I can't agree with you. Don't underestimate someone by counting the years in the showbiz. Even madonna was new to this world when she hit the charts with her debut album. It took a few years for her to become the queen. Who knows if gaga becomes the madonna of future. She has got the power and talent. Unlike spears and aguilera who...

    ReplyDelete
  6. I disagree Munwar - madonna came out the box an icon and continues to evolve - never copying another pop star! She paid homage a million times and sited it as inspiration. In turn I was turned on to art, photography, clasic films, film icons, etc. via Madonna's transformations. GaGa teaches me nothing. I also don't like her insinuating that all gay men are tortured - some of us are just fine!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have a 14 year old daughter and when I think back to when I was 14, that was when the Madonna-mania started. And thank God for it, because music and videos and concerts would have certainly been a heck of a lot poorer now with no imagination without her influence. Lady GeeGee isn't worthy to even clean Madonnas' boots than try to mimic her.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Munawar
    First I still say you can not compare a 30-year career with a 3 year one, we can compare when Gaga will have 30-year career, by then, it's impossible.
    Or so it seems to imply that in 3 years Gaga has contributed more to music than Madonna in 30 years? Let me laugh!
    Secondly, how not to underestimate a singer who plunders the career of another. It's not inspiration, or even a tribute, it's outright plunder. Where is the originality? You talk about talent, but which one? That of impersonator? Early in her career Madonna has not had to imitate anyone. She was herself, that's the huge difference.
    Third, I think Gaga owes much to the Internet, I'm not sure she would be as successful without it. When Madonna started, there was no Internet when you see the phenomenal success she had without it, it leaves you wonder what would have been this success with it...

    ReplyDelete
  9. The biggest issue I have with this whole affair is that The Grammys are celebrating Lady Ripoff now and they completely snubbed Madonna when she released Like A Prayer, the vintage Madonna period that recieved global critical acclaim and which GAGa is now pillaging. What. The. Fuck? Guess the Like A Prayer video was too controversial for them to feel safe touching anything to do with the project at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. By the way Pud, please publicise this:

    Express Yourself: International Download Day

    http://www.facebook.com/?ref=home#!/event.php?eid=151898824866835

    Lets get Express Yourself to no.1, where it belongs x

    ReplyDelete
  12. gaga is such a creepy thing. hope this news is true and gets more publicity. and OMG look at those photos: the beauty & the beast!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Why doesn't GAGA buy a life!!! she looks like ALF's sister! will gaga also come from MELMAK?

    ReplyDelete
  14. i personally don't care who takes or doesn't take home a grammy award. of course, i am happy when madonna gets the rare opportunity to take home a gold statue, but in all honesty, it's just another hyped-up award show with self-serving celebrities and musicians.

    we all know madonna is a fantastic performer/singer; we don't need that knowledge set in stone or "made official" through the winning of some awards.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Jeremy you're absolutely right! Paul McCartney in this year's ceremony received his first (!!!) grammy (i don't count the lifetime acchievement grammy in 1990) in his 37-years solo career and gaga for ex. has 5 grammies in 2 and a half years. awards are a joke and have nothing to do with the talent.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Mystery machine, in one matter i'm completely with you that madonna's outbreak was in a time before internet and pollings. She's the real super or megastar indeed. But if we make fun on gaga with this, no any artist will be considered as talented. There won't be no place for britney, beyonce, rihanna or that fuckin justin bieber... Many of the stars got shimmered after an initial shine like spears, aguilera and miley cyrus. where are they now? But i believe that gaga's gonna survive. The worst thing i hate in gaga is her sense of fashion that doesn't seem to be of a human at all... Whenever she appears in public, she looks like an alien or an animal. But there are fools to call it fashion.

    ReplyDelete
  17. oh, that lady gaga is just plain putrid.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi Puddy... At last you've opened up! I wondering why you're being silent :-) Waiting for more from you dude...

    ReplyDelete
  19. I don't know if Gaga will have a long career but she will have to be really creative .
    And learn that creativity is not wearing ridiculous clothes or looting the career of another singer

    ReplyDelete