Which Do You Prefer - Now or Then?

There seems to be much debate among Madonna's fan base about her face. At 52, I think she looks gorgeous and fantastic. I love all incarnations of Madonna but I think she looks better than she has in years. I want her to glow on forever.

Which do you prefer?

Footage of Madonna and Lourdes Walking Down the Red Carpet at Nine Premiere

The Star for the stars.

Madonna and Lourdes at Nine Premiere